Australia's controversial policy to restrict social networking access for young people below 16 is creating waves around the globe. Lawmakers, child protection groups, and parents are watching intently to see if this tactic will inspire imitation for other nations.
European Momentum
In Europe, a rising chorus of nations are exploring parallel restrictions.
- Denmark plans a prohibition on social media for under-15s, with the prime minister arguing that mobile devices and networks are "stealing our kids' childhood". The policy may be enacted next year.
- The Norwegian government is preparing to introduce a age restriction of 15, pointing to the need to shield children from the "manipulative force of the recommendation systems".
- The Irish government is working on a online verification tool to verify the user details of social media users. The media minister have stated that an Australian-model ban is "an tools under consideration".
- In Spain, the president has called on the legislature to pass a law increasing the legal age for accessing social media to 16.
- In The French government, the president has proposed a ban for those under fifteen, and a parliamentary commission has recommended a comparable step, potentially involving an overnight "screen time restriction" for adolescents.
- The government in The Netherlands has urged families to prevent their kids from social media until 15.
For the broader EU, the bloc's legislature has passed a symbolic statement calling for a ban for under-16s without a parent decides otherwise is provided. Although it warns of the "compulsive" design of these apps, the move does not enact binding law.
"An effective age barrier is a useful starting point," said a leading MEP supporting the measure.
The UK: An Evidence-Based Stance
For the United Kingdom, the administration has kept open a potential ban, arguing that "no measure is off the table" but stressing any action must be "supported by strong research".
Last year, momentum grew behind a legislative effort to enact controls on social media use by minors, but it was in the end modified. Nonetheless, the administration pledged to conduct more studies the matter.
Charities have expressed apprehensions. A prominent charity established by the family of a teenager who died after being exposed to dangerous online content contends that a simple age ban might not make platforms safer and could create a "dangerous transition" of harm when young people become eligible.
"Australia's ban is a reaction to the refusal of the social media companies to design platforms and apps that are safe and fit for children," said a leading online safety campaigner.
The United States: A Decentralized Landscape
Stateside, action is mostly happening at the local government level amid federal inaction.
- The state of Utah demands guardian permission for under-18s to use social media and controls nighttime use.
- Florida has signed a law banning those below 14 from accessing social media, though it is entangled in legal challenges.
- The state of Virginia has approved a rule limiting minors to one hour of social media time per day, with additional access requiring parental permission.
- Georgia, Tennessee, and The state of Louisiana have likewise enacted bills demanding guardian approval for teenagers to create social media accounts.
Despite bipartisan support and proposals from some politicians to follow the Australian path, a nationwide ban is right now seen as a distant prospect.
Global Perspectives
Outside of Europe and the US, other states are likewise exploring options.
- Malaysia aims to restrict social media for those under sixteen beginning next year.
- The Brazilian authorities has increased the required age for the platform Instagram to 16.
Yet, international bodies adopt a more cautious position. Unicef has warned that age-based restrictions have downsides and "might prove counterproductive". The organization notes that the internet can be a "vital connection" for isolated youth and that bans should not be a "substitute" for tech companies to invest in child safeguards.
While this international discussion continues, the actions of the Australian government and several other countries indicate that governments around the world are increasingly content to delay for tech companies to make changes on their own.